Sunday, 27 May 2012

A Reply from the Premier of Queensland

Hello All,

The hand written scrawl at the bottom of the second page I assume is the Premier's own hand.  I suspect this is the pro forma reply that everyone who has written to him on the subject has received.   Regardless, I propose to write another long, exhaustive reply and plea for him to at least consider and address obvious issues concerning Goldlinq's consultation and construction approach.  To date there has been no evidence of either their care, competence or craft. 

A lot of people have tried very hard to get the Light Rail Project reviewed (I notice the Premier's Office still refers to the project as Rapid Transit Project - makes you wonder whether they are following the details of the project or just fudging).  

Off my own bat I propose to initially fund an independent documentary on the project and its players.  I have had talks this last week with a company I once did work for in Sydney who have three such investigative projects already commissioned.  

Interestingly they have been looking at Public Private Partnership and questions of governance and outcomes.  There are a number of issues at the moment concerning Private Equity companies and how they are set-up to minimise losses and compensation claims once funding stops.  

The Carlyle Group is in the media at the moment and the $20 billion costs to Victorians for their desalination plant.  Also Sir Rod Eddington, Chairman of Infrastructure Australia is in the papers talking about pointless infrastructure projects (see article below) and stressing that the business case for any such projects must be conclusively made.  

For those of you who might not know - the novice Transport Minister Scott Emerson has refused to release the business case for the GCLR!  The why is clear.  The forecasting figures must be so irrelevant and misleading that any open investigation would destroy what little credibility any of the facilitators and players have in defending the project other than the obvious - to protect their outrageous commercial profits and pathetic self-serving arses.   

Goldlinq I suspect will be quite an interesting story from what I have so far learnt about its formation, which goes to the central construct of purpose: its commercial intent.  There's only going to be one winner out of this project and rest assured Goldlinq is a bigger odds-on favourite than Black Caviar. 

(Note:  Sir Rod Eddington is pushing for more Super Funds to invest in major infrastructure projects.  Only 30% do at the moment - and you wouldn't want to be in those funds when you look at the commercial returns from such investments.)

What I will be doing once the project is slated for production is asking as many of you to participate or forward information that might prove useful.  I suspect a lot of the stories will be personal ones regarding the destruction of businesses and lives due to this unexplained, inadequate, troubled and horrifically expensive tram to nowhere - eventually carrying only dashed hopes and debt to future generations of Gold Coasters.

I have also contacted the Crikey.com and The Global Mail two online newspapers that we all should read, support and promote.  They will consider the merits of a story once they go through all the forwarded material.  By now you'll realise that the Bulletin is Goldlinq's bugler.   It is a stinker of a paper, reflected not only in its plummeting circulation and advertising figures (dropped 7-8% in the last year - 30,000 per day  - only about 5% of the population buy it) but in its serial trashing and denigration of the Gold Coast and its people.  So of course they need to keep Goldlinq in business as it represents one of their biggest customers (public notices, the continually glossy lift-outs and flyers; employment and tender advertisements etc).  Unfortunately, we will have to put up with News Corp's commercial priorities and their desperate exaggerated headlines until it folds.  Hopefully that won't be long.

Outside of these initiatives, there may be legal options to consider but that again comes long after all the damage is done.  Hopefully pressure will be applied by our new mayor and councillors on Goldlinq to get their act together and finalise plans and institute proper business practises that will mitigate some of the damage to our beautiful and important tourist product - and to our lives.  That is the best we have got.  The local MP JP Langbroek has been spectacularly invisible and unwilling to represent our concerns and interests in this matter and has shown even less leadership qualities than he did when he was once leader of the LNP.  

Once again I ask you to forward this email to as many people as possible and sorry that I have been able to get back to you sooner or deliver some better news.  

All the best,
Matthew O'Sullivan

Please see below Message from the Premier of Queensland


Road to ruin warning from Sir Rod Eddington

THE Federal Government's leading adviser on roads, rail and ports has warned against a Greek-style binge on "bridges over puddles and roads to nowhere".
Sir Rod Eddington, who chairs the government body that reviews proposes big-ticket infrastructure projects, said the nation's arteries were under stress after two decades of underinvestment.
But he underlined the need to bring in private funding for vital projects and warned against simply funding them without undertaking rigorous studies into costs and benefits.
"If you build bridges over puddles and roads to nowhere, you do nothing for productivity," Sir Rod said, addressing the Australian British Chamber of Commerce in Melbourne yesterday.
"When Greece joined the euro and the (European Union) there was an enormous inflow of money into Greece for capital projects.
"They built a new airport, they built a huge facility for the Olympic games in 2004, they built a substantial new rail link. As I understands it, the stadium used for the Olympics stands empty and derelict ... the rail link runs at an operating loss of over 1 billion euros a year. It just did nothing for productivity and efficiency really."
"Japan is similar - they have big airports with runways that take 747s that are only used for model aeroplane clubs on the weekend."
Sir Rod also criticised the use of "strategic" rationales, rather than business cases, for major projects to be funded.
"If someone says a project is strategically important it usually means the business case doesn't stack up," he said.
And with the long timeframe required for important public projects, he said the Government needed to spur economic growth now with an aggressive reform program.
Sir Rod said business leaders were expressing fears about changes in industrial relations laws that threatened to hit productivity.
He said other key concerns included the duplication of red tape - particularly environmental regulation - between the Federal and state governments and the high cost of bidding for projects.
"If you want to see real productivity improvements it is through regulatory reform," Sir Rod said.
"If you go back to the early '80s, when Bob Hawke became prime minister in '83 ... (key initiatives included) the floating of the Australian dollar, the setting free of the Reserve Bank, the lowering of tariff barriers.
"All these things were painful, difficult, much debated issues. I would argue they sowed the seeds of the productivity enhancements of the next 20 years."

Tuesday, 17 April 2012

Gold Coast Light Rail - Concerns and Reasons for Review - by Alan Midwood


Could you read Alan Midwood's simple and clear overview and case for a Commission of Audit Review:
Gold Coast Light Rail - Concerns and Reasons for Review - by Alan Midwood.

It is an overview that warrants respect and consideration by responsible government representatives. Alan is a extremely conservative and sound thinker, who is more qualified than most to give an educated and financial perspective to this project.  It should be a concern to all of us that he is having trouble being heard.  

Could you please consider emailing or writing to the list of elected representatives and government officials (also please forward this request to other concerned or interested parties).
Please email or write to as many of our representatives as possible.

Even though we now have thousands of signatures asking for a review, plus 400 or more businesses, tourist attractions and service providers requesting the same thing - we are still not getting in a door.  A door that we thought we had opened at the last election.  We only want the Newman Government to acknowledge the CanDo Contract with the Gold Coast.  A contract we didn't ask for but which unequivocally commits to reviewing large infrastructure projects to cost/benefit analysis (read Light Rail).  Obviously it was offered in good faith and we still hold out hope that it will be honoured.   We definitely need to ask and ask again our local Members of Parliament to action our request and to do so because it is not only justified and reasonable, but it fulfils expectations that our new government will adopt better standards of evaluation, decision-making and accountability.  

Thank-you.

"I guess my main motivation for opposing GCLR is that I hate to see waste, and especially gross waste of public money, which inevitably leads to yet more rises in rates and taxes..
 
Gold Coast can have a much better and less expensive public transport system by using a Rapid Bus system  such as Brisbane enjoys.  All the experts agree,  and I have lots of documentary evidence to prove it.  The big difference is the cost of all the track work and overhead cabling that GoldlinQ are about to start building.  None of that is necessary for a Rapid Bus system, and none of the consequent devastation to businesses over the next 24 months.
 
Light Rail was chosen for 3 reasons :-  1.  Its cost was grossly under estimated by a factor of FOUR,  2.  The growth rate of the population of the "coastal corridor" was over estimated by a factor of FOUR,  3.  A company that develops Light Rail systems, (Parsons Brinckerhoff)  was engaged to compare the two systems ( and they negligently prepared the cost estimates).The process by which this happened is set out in the 4 page "History of Gold Coast Light Rail" that I prepared recently and I can email to interested parties.
 
The Light Rail system that is now being offered is no longer the scheme that GCCC approved in January 2005.  It was originally 17km long from Parkwood railway station to Hooker Boulevard.  It was to have 1,000 space Park & Ride car parks at Parkwood and Loders Creek.  It was to take "less than half an hour" for the full journey and cost $320 -  $360 million.    It now only runs 13km;  there is no provision for car parking at any of the 16 stops;  it is scheduled to take 37 minutes for the full journey and is costing four times as much. None of this is the fault of GoldlinQ, who took over the design from the Bligh Labor government's traffic engineers.
 
Whilst these major changes were taking place the government produced a Preliminary Business Case which was supposed to prove beyond doubt its viability.  But it was immediately declared confidential and has remained under wraps since its completion in August 2008.  I would dearly love to view this document and it should now be available to the Newman LNP government.  More to the point, the Commission of Audit should REVIEW that document and subsequent dealings before GoldlinQ start chopping down trees and digging up the road in Surfers Paradise and Southport. 
 
GCLR was originally to be an entirely private enterprise development, but when no private companies showed any interest in putting in equity the desperate government decided on a cooperative approach with the private sector.  Finally, it is our understanding that it is a PPP,  with the taxpayers of Queensland taking full responsibility for the total cost including all operating losses, and GoldlinQ acting effectively as a sub-contractor.  This is a classic example of Labor's irresponsible attitude to the expenditure of huge amounts of public money --  it seems that once a project gets into the Billions, everyone loses perspective.
 
This isolated 13km length of track does not "integrate seamlessly" with the rest of the city's public transport system in any way.  It will be a roadblock to the efficient operation of the bus network that serves the rest of the city,  until it is eventually ripped up and replaced by a seamlessly integrated bus system such as Brisbane's.  Once its losses are realised in operation it will never be extended for the remaining 26km to complete the original concept of a line running from Parkwood/Helensvale stations to the airport.  Without a connection to the Brisbane rail line it makes no sense at all.  In fact it would make a lot more sense to run it from Parkwood/Helensvale to Southport if we must hang on to the GoldlinQ contract.  It would at least help to service the city's major growth area.
 
But it would make a lot more sense to install a Rapid Bus system now, so that it can expand incrementally as demand for public transport grows.  Dumping an alien system into the middle of a bus network can only make the city's public transport problems worse.  In addition it will further increase  congestion on the roads due to passengers having to move across the normal traffic to the tram stops in the centre of the road.  This was the main reason why Brisbane abandoned its trams some 40 years ago.
 
Leading world authority Professor Bent Flyvbjerg of Oxford University has studied 44 Light Rail systems around the world and found, on average, they attract 51% FEWER passengers than forecast - echoes of the Clem 7 tunnel !  One quarter of the schemes got only one third of the forecast.  GCLR looks to be heading for that group, as people can't use it if they can't walk to it, as there is nowhere to park the car which they must use to drive from home.  This is a peculiarly Gold Coast problem as our streets were designed around the motor car in the second half of the 20th century.  A fact that has never been understood by the designers of GCLR.
 
That is why we are calling for the Commission of Audit to REVIEW this project as promised during the election campaign in No.3 of the Five Fiscal Principles to Reduce Labor's $85 Billion Debt in "Our contract with The Gold Coast".  As the facts are becoming known to the public the LNP government will have the necessary backing to take this action.   The public has a right to know what the debt obligations are through a Cost/Benefit Analysis before the contract is allowed to continue.  The 2008 one is clearly out of date, so a new and realistic one needs to be prepared immediately.
 
The first thing anyone says when you suggest a review of Light Rail is that it is too late.  It's not too late.  There is an escape clause in GoldlinQ's contract that enables the new Queensland government to review and amend or cancel it in the best interests of Queenslanders.  Compensation will be due to GoldlinQ of course, but that will be minor by comparison with the huge cost of going ahead with a project that will totally fail in its main aim of reducing traffic congestion.
 
If the government adopts the "Do nothing" approach, I hope you will keep this email and look back on it when Light Rail has been operating for a few years, and the interest and operating losses are spiralling and adding to Queensland's debt burden,  and think "Yes, we could have done something about it, if only we had acted then."
 
Alan Midwood
 PLEASE EMAIL OR WRITE TO AS MANY OF OUR REPRESENTATIVES AS POSSIBLE:

Premier Campbell Newman: thepremier@premiers.qld.gov.au
Director-General Premier's Office John Bradley: Director.General@premiers.qld.gov.au

Deputy Premier John Seeney: deputypremier@ministerial.qld.gov.au (Minister for State Development and Infrastructure and Planning)

Surfer MP and Education Minister John-Paul Langbroek: surfers.paradise@lnpqld.org.au 

Minister for Transport Scott Emerson:  indooroopilly@parliament.qld.gov.au
Director-General Transport and Main Roads michael.caltabiano@tmr.qld.gov.au
Assistant Minister Steve Minnikin (Public Transport) 
Deputy D.G Investment and Program Development paul.t.smith@tmr.qld.gov.au
Associate D.G Policy & Planning Mark Cridland mark.a.cridland@tmr.qld.gov.au

Treasurer Tim Nicholls: treasurer@ministerial.qld.gov.au
Under Secretary for Treasury Gerard Bradley: gerard.bradley@treasury.qld.gov.au


Minister for Tourism Jan Stuckey: tourism@ministerial.qld.gov.au


Local Members:



Ros Bates:  (Mudgeeraba) ScienceandIT@ministerial.qld.gov.au 


Rob Molhoek:  Southport@parliament.qld.gov.au    






Edinburgh Light Rail Halted


Hi All,

Could you read this story about the Edinburgh Light Rail Infrastructure Project being halted. 

Edinburgh Light Rail Halted. The Usual Suspects. The Usual Results

This is an article in the Hawaii Reporter linking the same mistakes in underestimating costs and overestimating outcomes in three current projects involving the same players (planners, forecasters, developers, facilitators).  The article warns of the same disastrous outcomes for Honolulu's light rail project.  I am thinking much closer to home.



BY PANOS PREVEDOUROS PHD - Edinburgh Light Rail called Edinburgh Trams is the second great example of what’s in store for Honolulu. The first one is Tren Urbano in San Juan Puerto Rico where the system was build at twice the original cost and five years after opening it has failed to reach 50% of its opening year ridership forecast.
The “usual suspect” is present in all three projects. Edinburgh, San Juan and Honolulu have the same consultant who prepared the rail project estimates. Here are the results so far in Edinburgh, Scotland:
  • Project originally scheduled to open in July 2011. Rescheduled to 2014 if at all.
  • Original cost was $640 million but now it over $1 Billion.
  • 72% of the construction work remains to be done but only 38% of the budget is left.
Efforts to get Edinburgh's troubled trams project back on track now seem certain to drag on beyond the Scottish Parliament elections in May. Edinburgh Conservative David McLetchie said: "If people are delaying because they think more money will be forthcoming from any new Scottish Government, they had better think again. My party, and I believe others, are quite resolved there will be not a penny more than the original £500m that was committed and it is up to the city to meet any extra costs." [1]
This is an important lesson to Honolulu. Federal bailout dollars are highly unlikely.
This Scotsman title says a lot: Keeping track of this fiasco is easier said than done. They summarized it as follows in the following five paragraphs: [2]
Although the disputed issues have been repeatedly described as "complex", they actually boil down to two simple facts: 1) the council has signed a legally binding contract with the tram consortium to build a tram line between Edinburgh Airport and Newhaven; and 2) it has insufficient money (and has secured no additional funding), to complete the works. With the council liable for construction costs over the £500 million Scottish Government grant, that is desperately worrying for local taxpayers.
How, in a few short years, has the tram project gone from being the "vital" jewel in Edinburgh's shining crown to a potentially catastrophic financial millstone round its neck?
The answer, again, is simple: over-optimism, arrogance, and a systemic failure on the part of professionals to protect the public interest and purse.
Fears that underground utility diversions would be significant, complex and time-consuming were patronizingly dismissed with assurances that super-duper, high-tech radar technology had located all underground pipes; and, crucially, the public need not fear significant cost increases because risk had been transferred to the private sector under "fixed price" contracts.
The army of private sector engineers, transportation modelers, transportation planners, environmental consultants, property experts, accountants and lawyers, having received protracted and generous recompense for their expertise, have also failed to ensure issues were resolved.
Honolulu is clearly no different: Subservient professionals offer politicians what they want to hear, and clueless politicians believe all of it. Poor planning and bad government guarantee a financial fiasco. Honolulu has all the components for a bad outcome.
Meanwhile, the economic losses at both public and private sector are very real. Edinburgh trams: Three years of hurt for nothing: [3]
  • Traders whose livelihoods have been blighted by the trams project have spoken of their anger over the news that the route could be cut short.
  • Business owners on Leith Walk have suffered three years of disruption as tram works were carried out outside their premises.
  • And much like Honolulu, Edinburgh ordered trains that it cannot use… [4]

Wednesday, 11 April 2012

Dear Friends and a few others :)


Dear Friend (and a few others I am not so friendly with but hoping for better relations)

Having spoken to well over 300 business owners and many many more ratepayers I am convinced that no one, least of all those who were responsible for ushering in the Light Rail Project, had any idea of the monstrous costs and the disastrous consequences this project is going to inflict on the Gold Coast  region and ratepayers.

Thank goodness that the Gold Coast Residents and Ratepayers Association have stepped in to demand a reassessment of the Light Rail Project.  

I ask again for you to come, and bring and encourage others, to tonight's meeting at the Gold Coast Arts Centre (Paradise Room at 6pm) to consider a more open and detailed assessment of the Light Rail Project.  

It is not TOO LATE for sensible people to step up and demand a review of the project.

Again I ask for you to email this to others and to download the petition and ask people to consider and sign.

Thanks for your understanding and consideration of this serious matter.

THE FOLLOWING SUMMARY ARE OUR CONCERNS - THIS IS BY THE WORLD'S LEADING EXPERT - AND IT'S ALL RELEVANT TO OUR ASSESSMENT AND POSITION IN ASKING FOR A REVIEW. (His papers on the subjects are attached)

Professor Bent Flyvbjerg is the first Chair and BT Professor of Major Programme Management at Oxford University's Saïd Business School and is Founding Director of the University's BT Centre for Major Programme Management. He was previously Professor of Planning at Aalborg University, Denmark and Chair of Infrastructure Policy and Planning at Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands. Flyvbjerg received his Ph.D. in economic geography from Aarhus University, Denmark. He has written extensively about megaprojects, decision making, city management, and philosophy of social science. He was knighted in Denmark in 2002.
 
Here is the link to his home page at Oxford: http://www.sbs.ox.ac.uk/research/people/Pages/BentFlyvbjerg.aspx
Prof Flyvbjerg developed research methodology for use in studies of city management and of major infrastructure and megaprojects. In 2009 he published the attached article in the Oxford Review of Economic Policy.
His papers document a study of 258 infrastructure projects carried out in 20 nations on 5 continents over a 70 year period from 1927 to 1998. 44 of these were urban rail projects undertaken over a 30 year period from 1969 to 1998. He notes that despite 70 years of experience on megaprojects and 30 years on urban rail, the accuracy of forecasts of costs and passenger demand have not improved. The error margins are the same today as they were over past decades.

Tuesday, 10 April 2012

Cavill Mall makeover hammers trade

 CAVILL Mall traders -- dreading the effect construction of the city's light rail system will have on their businesses -- are already having to cope with a bombsite outside their doors.

A $7 million makeover of the mall in the heart of Surfers Paradise is causing headaches as workmen use jackhammers to break up concrete. Please read the full story at http://www.goldcoast.com.au/article/2012/04/10/406631_gold-coast-news.html

St. Anthony: Hoping to ride out light-rail construction

In the long run, the Central Corridor project that will link downtown Minneapolis and St. Paul is supposed to be good for business. In the short run, it's been a rough road for hundreds of small businesses that front the $957 million construction project. And for fledgling entrepreneur Carla Harris, who opened a Quiznos sandwich shop last fall on the east edge of the University of Minnesota just in time for heavy construction outside her front door, it could be the end of the road. Please read the full story at Startribune.com