Gold Coast can have a much better and less expensive public transport system by using a Rapid Bus system such as Brisbane enjoys. All the experts agree, and I have lots of documentary evidence to prove it. The big difference is the cost of all the track work and overhead cabling that GoldlinQ are about to start building. None of that is necessary for a Rapid Bus system, and none of the consequent devastation to businesses over the next 24 months.
Light Rail was chosen for 3 reasons :- 1. Its cost was grossly under estimated by a factor of FOUR, 2. The growth rate of the population of the "coastal corridor" was over estimated by a factor of FOUR, 3. A company that develops Light Rail systems, (Parsons Brinckerhoff) was engaged to compare the two systems ( and they negligently prepared the cost estimates).The process by which this happened is set out in the 4 page "History of Gold Coast Light Rail" that I prepared recently and I can email to interested parties.
The Light Rail system that is now being offered is no longer the scheme that GCCC approved in January 2005. It was originally 17km long from Parkwood railway station to Hooker Boulevard. It was to have 1,000 space Park & Ride car parks at Parkwood and Loders Creek. It was to take "less than half an hour" for the full journey and cost $320 - $360 million. It now only runs 13km; there is no provision for car parking at any of the 16 stops; it is scheduled to take 37 minutes for the full journey and is costing four times as much. None of this is the fault of GoldlinQ, who took over the design from the Bligh Labor government's traffic engineers.
Whilst these major changes were taking place the government produced a Preliminary Business Case which was supposed to prove beyond doubt its viability. But it was immediately declared confidential and has remained under wraps since its completion in August 2008. I would dearly love to view this document and it should now be available to the Newman LNP government. More to the point, the Commission of Audit should REVIEW that document and subsequent dealings before GoldlinQ start chopping down trees and digging up the road in Surfers Paradise and Southport.
GCLR was originally to be an entirely private enterprise development, but when no private companies showed any interest in putting in equity the desperate government decided on a cooperative approach with the private sector. Finally, it is our understanding that it is a PPP, with the taxpayers of Queensland taking full responsibility for the total cost including all operating losses, and GoldlinQ acting effectively as a sub-contractor. This is a classic example of Labor's irresponsible attitude to the expenditure of huge amounts of public money -- it seems that once a project gets into the Billions, everyone loses perspective.
This isolated 13km length of track does not "integrate seamlessly" with the rest of the city's public transport system in any way. It will be a roadblock to the efficient operation of the bus network that serves the rest of the city, until it is eventually ripped up and replaced by a seamlessly integrated bus system such as Brisbane's. Once its losses are realised in operation it will never be extended for the remaining 26km to complete the original concept of a line running from Parkwood/Helensvale stations to the airport. Without a connection to the Brisbane rail line it makes no sense at all. In fact it would make a lot more sense to run it from Parkwood/Helensvale to Southport if we must hang on to the GoldlinQ contract. It would at least help to service the city's major growth area.
But it would make a lot more sense to install a Rapid Bus system now, so that it can expand incrementally as demand for public transport grows. Dumping an alien system into the middle of a bus network can only make the city's public transport problems worse. In addition it will further increase congestion on the roads due to passengers having to move across the normal traffic to the tram stops in the centre of the road. This was the main reason why Brisbane abandoned its trams some 40 years ago.
Leading world authority Professor Bent Flyvbjerg of Oxford University has studied 44 Light Rail systems around the world and found, on average, they attract 51% FEWER passengers than forecast - echoes of the Clem 7 tunnel ! One quarter of the schemes got only one third of the forecast. GCLR looks to be heading for that group, as people can't use it if they can't walk to it, as there is nowhere to park the car which they must use to drive from home. This is a peculiarly Gold Coast problem as our streets were designed around the motor car in the second half of the 20th century. A fact that has never been understood by the designers of GCLR.
That is why we are calling for the Commission of Audit to REVIEW this project as promised during the election campaign in No.3 of the Five Fiscal Principles to Reduce Labor's $85 Billion Debt in "Our contract with The Gold Coast". As the facts are becoming known to the public the LNP government will have the necessary backing to take this action. The public has a right to know what the debt obligations are through a Cost/Benefit Analysis before the contract is allowed to continue. The 2008 one is clearly out of date, so a new and realistic one needs to be prepared immediately.
The first thing anyone says when you suggest a review of Light Rail is that it is too late. It's not too late. There is an escape clause in GoldlinQ's contract that enables the new Queensland government to review and amend or cancel it in the best interests of Queenslanders. Compensation will be due to GoldlinQ of course, but that will be minor by comparison with the huge cost of going ahead with a project that will totally fail in its main aim of reducing traffic congestion.
If the government adopts the "Do nothing" approach, I hope you will keep this email and look back on it when Light Rail has been operating for a few years, and the interest and operating losses are spiralling and adding to Queensland's debt burden, and think "Yes, we could have done something about it, if only we had acted then."